Sir Gavin Williamson accused teachers of looking for an “excuse” not to work during the COVID-19 pandemic, according to leaked messages from Matt Hancock published by The Daily Telegraph.
In May 2020, as teachers prepared for classrooms to reopen, the then education secretary had messaged Mr Hancock asking for help in securing personal protective equipment (PPE) for schools.
He said this was so staff could not use a lack of it as “a reason not to open”.
Politics live: Government ‘considered ordering death of all pet cats’
He added: “All of them will but some will just want to say they can’t so they have an excuse to avoid having to teach, what joys!!!”
It was a rather different view to the one he expressed in public that same month, praising teachers for “going above and beyond the call of duty”, adding: “You have simply been outstanding and we are so grateful for what you’ve done”.
Five months later, Mr Hancock messaged Sir Gavin to congratulate him on his decision to delay A-level exams for a few weeks, due to the virus.
Mr Hancock, then the health secretary, wrote: “Cracking announcement today.
“What a bunch of absolute arses the teaching unions are.”
Sir Gavin responded: “I know they really really do just hate work.”
Mr Hancock’s reply was two laughing face emojis and a bullseye.
Read More:
The key exchanges
‘I broke NDA, but it wasn’t personal’
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
Geoff Barton tells Sky News the alleged comments by the former education secretary are ‘pretty squalid’
Analysis: Explosive messages lay bare political handling of the pandemic
On Wednesday night Williamson tweeted what he claimed were clarifications about his messages, saying it was certain unions, not teachers themselves that he was criticising.
He tweeted: “Further to reports in the Telegraph and other outlets, I wish to clarify that these messages were about some Unions and not teachers.
“As demonstrated in the exchange, I was responding regarding Unions. I have the utmost respect for teachers who work tirelessly to support students.
“During the pandemic, teachers went above and beyond during very challenging times and very much continue to do so.”
Hancock and Williamson clash over school closures
The files obtained by The Telegraph also appear to show a behind the scenes clash between Mr Hancock and Sir Gavin in December 2020 over whether schools should reopen as the second wave of COVID took hold.
After the then education secretary persuaded Boris Johnson to keep classrooms open, Mr Hancock is said to have text one of his aides saying they needed to fight a “rear-guard action” to prevent a “policy car crash”.
Matt Hancock
The exchange took place during a Zoom meeting about school closures, when Mr Hancock’s special adviser Emma Dean said the education secretary was “freaking out”, adding: “You can tell he isn’t being wholly rational. Just by his body language.”
Mr Hancock replied: “I’m having to turn the volume down.”
At the end of the meeting, Mr Hancock said: “I want to find a way, Gavin having won the day, of actually preventing a policy car crash when the kids spread the disease in January. And for that we must now fight a rear-guard action.”
How were the WhatsApps leaked?
The Telegraph said the messages show he then contacted Dan Rosenfield, Mr Johnson’s chief of staff, to begin his attempt to have schools closed before children returned, providing him with his private email address.
In the event, on 4 January, after many younger children had returned to classes for a single day, Mr Johnson announced schools would close and exams would be cancelled amid a national lockdown. They did not reopen until 8 March 2021.
Click to subscribe to the Sky News Daily wherever you get your podcasts
Leaked messages ‘pretty squalid’
Geoff Barton, the general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders union, said the reported messages are “pretty squalid”.
He told Sky News: “Those comments are denigrating, stereotyping teachers when they were the very people who the nation needed to focus on young people in the way that the government hadn’t.”
He said the debate around schools reopening had become very contentious during the pandemic – particularly in regard to whether face masks should be worn – and firm leadership was needed rather than “political government by WhatsApp“.
He added: “Thing thing I regret, after 30 odd years in education, I want the brightest and best young people in our country to choose to go into politics because they can make a difference. Well, they’ll be reading those WhatsApp messages and thinking that’s the last place I want to go, and shame on those politicians for the way they conduct themselves.”
Bridget Phillipson, Labour’s shadow education secretary, also said the comments “are a kick in the teeth for teachers who stretched every sinew for children during the pandemic”.
“They add insult to injury at a time when fewer people are joining the profession, and when teachers are leaving classrooms in their droves.”
The decision to first close schools was made by the government in March 2020, although some schools had already made the choice for themselves.
Over the following year, children endured a rollercoaster of reopenings and closures, as the country tried to strike a balance between containing the virus and resuming normal life
Unions and schools had repeatedly said they did not want to put teachers or vulnerable children at risk.
But the government also faced a problem in that parents were having to stay home to look after children during school closures, preventing them from returning fully to work.
A number of reports since then have documented the negative consequences for students.
In January 2021, research from the Social Mobility Foundation said the closures could wipe out a decade of progress closing the gap between less privileged pupils and their peers.
And in May 2021, a study by think tank Social Finance found that disadvantaged children were the least likely to return to school after lockdown.
A spokesman for Mr Hancock said: “Tonight’s revelations are exactly like last night’s. These are partial accounts, obviously spun with an agenda.
“They show Matt was focused throughout on saving lives. The right place for a full assessment is the (official Covid) inquiry.”